AnySelected

GST Relief for Health & Life Insurance: A Double-Edged Sword?

South African insurers are cautiously welcoming recent changes to Goods and Services Tax (GST) regarding health and life insurance premiums. While the move aims to provide relief to consumers struggling with rising costs, industry experts are warning that a zero-rated system could inadvertently lead to increased premiums and a weakening of existing tax credits.

The government's decision to remove GST from health and life insurance policies is undoubtedly a positive step. It effectively reduces the overall cost of these vital protections for individuals and families. However, the devil, as they say, is in the details. Insurers are raising concerns about the potential impact on their operational costs and the sustainability of the current tax credit system.

Understanding the Current System & Input Tax Credits

Currently, insurance companies are able to claim Input Tax Credits (ITCs) on a significant portion of their backend expenses. These expenses are crucial for running a robust and efficient insurance operation and include:

• Insurance Commission: Payments made to brokers and agents for selling policies.
• Re-insurance: Insurance purchased by insurance companies to protect against large losses.
• Technology: Investment in IT infrastructure and software vital for policy management, claims processing, and data security.
• Customer Support: Costs associated with providing excellent service to policyholders, including call centers and online support.
• Distribution Expenses: Costs related to marketing, advertising, and reaching potential customers.

These ITCs effectively reduce the amount of VAT that insurers need to pay, contributing to the overall affordability of insurance products.

The Zero-Rating Dilemma: Potential for Higher Costs

Removing GST from premiums while simultaneously eliminating ITCs on backend costs creates a potential imbalance. Without the ability to offset these expenses with ITCs, insurers may be forced to pass these costs onto consumers in the form of higher premiums. This could negate the intended benefit of the GST relief, particularly for lower-income individuals who rely on affordable insurance coverage.

Furthermore, the erosion of tax credits could impact the viability of certain insurance products, especially those with lower profit margins. This could lead to reduced choice and less competition in the market.

Finding a Sustainable Solution

Industry bodies are actively engaging with the government to explore potential solutions that mitigate these risks. Suggestions include:

• Phased Implementation: A gradual transition to the zero-rated system to allow insurers time to adjust.
• Alternative ITC Mechanisms: Exploring alternative ways for insurers to offset their backend costs.
• Review of Tax Credits: A comprehensive review of the existing tax credit system to ensure it remains effective and sustainable.

Looking Ahead

The recent changes to GST on health and life insurance premiums represent a significant shift in the South African insurance landscape. While the intention is laudable – to ease the financial burden on consumers – careful consideration must be given to the potential unintended consequences. Open dialogue between the government and the insurance industry is crucial to ensure a sustainable and equitable outcome for all stakeholders. Consumers should remain informed and monitor any changes to their insurance policies and tax implications.