AnySelected

In the ever-evolving landscape of NFL hindsight, few decisions spark as much debate as the 2016 draft. The Atlanta Falcons, coming off a promising season, held the 5th overall pick and faced a pivotal choice. While they opted for defensive tackle Grady Jarrett, a Pro Bowl talent in his own right, many fans and analysts question whether passing on safety Keanu Neal was a significant misstep.

Neal, a standout performer at the University of Florida, initially appeared destined for stardom in Atlanta's secondary. His rookie season was undeniably impressive, showcasing his tackling ability and coverage skills. He racked up 106 combined tackles and eight passes defended, demonstrating a physicality and instincts that suggested a long and prosperous career. The initial excitement surrounding Neal was palpable – many envisioned him as a cornerstone of the Falcons’ defense for years to come.

However, Jarrett’s selection proved to be a shrewd move in the long run. Jarrett blossomed into one of the league's premier interior defensive linemen, consistently disrupting offenses and commanding double teams. His impact on the Falcons’ defensive line was undeniable, and his Pro Bowl recognition validated the team’s faith in his potential. The Falcons' front office clearly saw a need for bolstering their defensive line, and Jarrett ultimately delivered.

So, why the continued discussion about Neal? The argument centers on the relative scarcity of impact safeties in the NFL. While good defensive tackles are valuable, truly elite safeties who can consistently impact games are significantly harder to find. Neal, despite experiencing some inconsistencies and injuries later in his career, possessed the raw talent and athleticism to potentially become that elite player. The Falcons' secondary struggled at times throughout the years following the draft, leading some to believe that Neal could have provided the stability and playmaking ability they desperately needed.

The “what if” scenario remains a compelling one. Would Neal have developed into a perennial Pro Bowler, anchoring the Falcons' secondary for a decade? Or would Jarrett's consistent dominance have solidified the pick as a clear win for Atlanta? Ultimately, it’s a question that can only be debated in retrospect. However, the discussion highlights the inherent difficulty in evaluating draft prospects and the unpredictable nature of player development. The Falcons made a calculated gamble, and while Jarrett proved to be a valuable asset, the allure of what could have been with Keanu Neal continues to linger in the minds of Falcons fans.

Looking back, the 2016 draft serves as a reminder that even the most well-informed decisions can be subject to scrutiny. It’s a testament to the complexities of team building and the enduring power of hindsight in the world of professional football. The Falcons' choice to prioritize Jarrett over Neal remains a fascinating case study in draft evaluation and a constant source of debate for fans and analysts alike.