Tim Bagley Reveals SNL Rejected Him Due to His Sexuality: 'They Wouldn't Hire Openly Gay People'

2025-06-18
Tim Bagley Reveals SNL Rejected Him Due to His Sexuality: 'They Wouldn't Hire Openly Gay People'
Entertainment Weekly

Tim Bagley's SNL Dream Dashed by Homophobia: A Revealing Interview

Veteran comedic actor Tim Bagley, known for his memorable roles in films like Elf and BoJack Horseman, has made a startling revelation about his early career aspirations. In a recent interview on SiriusXM’s The Julia Cunningham Show, Bagley, 67, disclosed that his hopes of joining the cast of Saturday Night Live were effectively shut down due to his sexual orientation.

Bagley recounted a disheartening experience where he was told that SNL, at the time, wasn't willing to hire openly gay performers. This revelation sheds light on a period when LGBTQ+ representation in mainstream comedy was significantly limited, and underscores the challenges faced by many talented individuals navigating the entertainment industry.

“I wanted to be on SNL so badly,” Bagley shared, his voice tinged with a mix of regret and understanding. “But I was told, quite frankly, that they wouldn’t hire openly gay people. It was just the climate at the time.”

A Changing Landscape in Comedy

Bagley’s experience highlights the evolution of attitudes and inclusivity within the entertainment world. While SNL has since featured several openly LGBTQ+ cast members, including Jane Lynch, Kate McKinnon, and currently, Sarah Sherman and Bowen Yang, the situation was markedly different decades ago. The early career rejection underscores a painful reality that many LGBTQ+ performers faced – the need to conceal their identities to secure opportunities.

Bagley’s candidness comes at a time when discussions about diversity, equity, and inclusion are increasingly prominent in the entertainment industry. His story serves as a reminder of the progress that has been made, but also of the ongoing work required to ensure a truly equitable and welcoming environment for all creators.

Continuing a Successful Career

Despite the setback with SNL, Bagley has enjoyed a long and successful career. He has appeared in numerous films and television shows, consistently demonstrating his comedic talent and versatility. His work on animated series like BoJack Horseman has garnered critical acclaim and a dedicated following.

Bagley’s willingness to share his story is commendable, offering a glimpse into a past where talent wasn't always enough, and personal identity could be a significant barrier to professional success. His openness is a testament to the power of sharing experiences and contributing to a broader conversation about inclusivity and representation in the entertainment industry.

The interview with The Julia Cunningham Show has sparked considerable discussion online, prompting many to reflect on the history of LGBTQ+ representation in comedy and the importance of continued progress toward a more inclusive future.

Recommendations
Recommendations