AnySelected

In a candid revelation, veteran actress Kathy Bates has shared a surprising story about a past casting rejection by the late Garry Marshall. Bates claims Marshall, a beloved director and producer known for his feel-good films, turned down her potential role in the film adaptation of 'Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune' – a role she originally played on stage – due to her appearance and a perceived lack of romantic appeal.

Bates, known for her powerful and often unconventional roles, recounted the incident during a recent interview. She explained that Marshall allegedly told her he didn't believe audiences would find her kissing a male co-star to be 'romantic.' This explanation has sparked considerable discussion and debate online, with many questioning Marshall's rationale and its implications regarding beauty standards and typecasting in Hollywood.

“I had done ‘Frankie and Johnny’ on Broadway, and Garry Marshall wanted to do the movie,” Bates explained. “He called me up and said, ‘Kathy, you were wonderful, but audiences won’t believe you kissing a man.’ I said, ‘Garry, I am an actress!’ He said, ‘It won’t work, it won’t be romantic.’ And that was that.”

The role of Frankie, a hardened waitress with a troubled past, eventually went to Michelle Pfeiffer. While Pfeiffer delivered a memorable performance, Bates' revelation sheds light on the sometimes-arbitrary and subjective nature of casting decisions in the entertainment industry. It also raises questions about the pressure actresses face to conform to conventional notions of beauty and desirability.

Marshall, who passed away in 2016, was a prolific filmmaker responsible for numerous successful comedies, including 'Pretty Woman,' 'Beaches,' and 'Armadillo.' His work was often characterized by its optimistic tone and focus on relationships. However, Bates' account presents a different, more complex side of the director, highlighting a potential rigidity in his vision of romantic casting.

Bates, a two-time Academy Award winner, is celebrated for her versatility and willingness to take on challenging roles, often defying expectations. Her story serves as a reminder that even established actresses can face unexpected obstacles and biases in their careers. The incident underscores the ongoing need for greater inclusivity and diversity in Hollywood, both in front of and behind the camera.

The story has resonated with many who have shared similar experiences of being overlooked or typecast due to their appearance. It has also reignited conversations about the importance of challenging conventional beauty standards and embracing a wider range of talent in the film industry. Whether Marshall’s reasoning was a misguided attempt to maximize commercial appeal or a reflection of deeper societal biases, Bates' account offers a compelling glimpse into the complexities of Hollywood casting and the enduring challenges faced by actresses.