Shiel's Forceful Push Costs Essendon Star a Game: AFL Tribunal Hands Down One-Match Ban
Shiel's Forceful Push Costs Essendon Star a Game: AFL Tribunal Hands Down One-Match Ban
Essendon fans are reeling after midfielder Dylan Shiel received a one-game suspension from the AFL tribunal following a concerning incident during the Bombers' match against Geelong. The incident, which occurred while contesting a loose ball, involved Shiel pushing Geelong’s Mark O’Connor into a contest. Unfortunately, the impact resulted in Essendon teammate Luamon Lual being forced off the field after landing awkwardly on his head and shoulder.
The match review panel immediately referred the incident to the tribunal, and after deliberations, Shiel was found guilty of rough conduct. The suspension marks a significant blow to Essendon’s midfield rotation, particularly as they navigate a challenging period in the season. The tribunal deemed the force of the push excessive and directly contributed to the injury sustained by Lual.
What Happened?
The play unfolded in a congested midfield battle. Shiel, attempting to win possession, executed a push on O’Connor. This push inadvertently propelled O’Connor into a position where he collided with Lual, who was attempting to compete for the ball. Lual landed heavily, visibly distressed, and was quickly attended to by medical staff before being substituted from the game.
Tribunal's Reasoning
The AFL tribunal acknowledged that Shiel’s intention wasn't to injure Lual. However, they emphasized that the force used in the push was beyond what’s considered acceptable in AFL, given the potential for such consequences. They considered the vulnerability of players competing for the ball and the resulting impact on Lual’s safety.
Impact on Essendon
Essendon coach Brad Scott expressed disappointment with the outcome, stating that while they respect the tribunal’s decision, the suspension is a setback. The loss of Shiel, a key player known for his hard-ball gets and run, will undoubtedly impact the team’s performance in the upcoming round. The club will need to adjust their midfield strategy and rely on other players to step up in his absence.
Luamon Lual’s Condition
While initial reports suggested a concussion, the full extent of Lual's injury is still being assessed. Essendon provided an update, indicating that he is currently undergoing observation and further tests will be conducted to determine his recovery timeline. The club’s priority is ensuring Lual’s wellbeing and a safe return to the field.
This incident highlights the ongoing challenges in balancing physicality and player safety in AFL. The tribunal's decision serves as a reminder to players to exercise caution and control their actions, even in the heat of the moment. Essendon now faces the challenge of adapting to Shiel’s absence and supporting Lual as he recovers from his injury, all while striving for success on the field.
