AnySelected

For many, 1998's The Parent Trap evokes cherished memories of twin shenanigans, a luxurious Californian vineyard, and a heartwarming reunion. But for Courtney Gilberto, who played the unforgettable Nicole, affectionately dubbed the 'tie-dye girl' by fans, the film's legacy held a darker side. In an exclusive interview with PEOPLE, Gilberto, now 26 years later, opens up about the bullying she faced after the movie's release and her journey to reclaim the joy and pride associated with her single, yet impactful, acting role.

Gilberto's portrayal of Nicole, the quirky and colourful friend of the twins, Hallie and Annie (Lindsay Lohan), remains etched in the memories of a generation. Her signature tie-dye shirt became an instant icon, and 'tie-dye girl' a beloved nickname. Yet, the sudden fame and attention that followed the film's success proved overwhelming for the then-young actress.

“It was really tough,” Gilberto admits. “Kids at school were saying things like, ‘There’s the Parent Trap girl,’ and it wasn’t always in a nice way. They’d mimic my character or tease me about the tie-dye shirt. It was a lot to handle at that age.” The relentless teasing and scrutiny led Gilberto to step away from acting, a decision she felt was necessary for her well-being.

After The Parent Trap, Gilberto pursued a different path, focusing on her education and building a career outside of the entertainment industry. She found fulfillment in a stable career and a more grounded life, deliberately distancing herself from the spotlight.

However, over the years, the outpouring of love and nostalgia for The Parent Trap never faded. Fans continued to seek her out, expressing their appreciation for her role and the enduring charm of the film. This positive response, coupled with a renewed sense of self-assurance, prompted Gilberto to reconsider her relationship with her past role.

“I’ve realised that ‘tie-dye girl’ is something to be proud of,” she says with a smile. “It’s a part of my story, and it brought so much joy to so many people. I’m finally able to embrace it without feeling self-conscious.” Gilberto now actively engages with fans online, sharing memories and reconnecting with the community that cherished her character. She is even exploring creative projects, demonstrating a newfound enthusiasm for storytelling and performance.

Gilberto’s story is a powerful reminder that fame and its consequences can be complex, especially for young people. Her journey from facing bullying to reclaiming her iconic role showcases resilience, self-discovery, and the enduring power of a beloved film. It’s a testament to the fact that even a single role can leave a lasting impact – both on the audience and the performer themselves. And for Courtney Gilberto, the 'tie-dye girl' is finally ready to shine again.